Ok, so below is the poem as it originally appeared, plus proposed changes that i'm thinking about after a dialog with Curtis about the poem. If people would be so kind as to give me their opinions about the changes, plus any other critical comments about the poem itself, i'd be grateful. Comments can be made directly on this page, or in an email to me (naj at uchicago.edu). If you comment on this page, please do so below the poem itself, and use stanza/line number in stanza (1-4) to refer to specifics.
I am the leaf limp on the branch
Scarlet turning slowly to orange brown
Then plunging gracefully through the frosty air
To the ground
- line 3: strike gracefully
- line 4: insert distant after the
I am the dying grass
Green in my morning, brown in my evening
Immune to the ravages of passing feet
But not to my caress
- line 1: replace dying with fading
- line 3-4: Is the ownership of passing feet clear? (not narrator)
I am the skeletal trees
Fingers reaching into space in greeting
And limbs poised to accept a dance
From the chill wind
- line 2: reword - Fingers thrust skyward in greeting
I am the grain that falls and the apple overripe
Left in the field long after all others are taken
I know that there is always rebirth
And always after, death
- line 2: reword - Abandoned to rot after the harvest
- line 3-4: Q: Is the juxtapositioning of rebirth and death jarring, or is it a sensical assertion in the context of the poem?
I am the voice that moans
Howling about your eaves while you think warm thoughts
Safely battened down in your fortress of wood and brick
Promises of darkness and cold
- line 2: strike 'think warm thoughts' and replace with tremble
- line 3: strike safely
I am the shadow of death
Harbinger of torpor and stasis; I await only the gravemaker
And the trees with their shivering hands reach to him in supplication
To bury all the world
I am the frosted claw that grips hearts and kills joy
I am the child scribbling on the slate before it is wiped clean
I am the sorrow beyond remembrance and the destiny beyond foretelling
I am the beginning of unbecoming
- line 2: strike 'child...clean' and replace with 'ancient man, eyes fixed beyond this world'